Ottawa lawyer Paul Champ, who has fought many human rights cases involving security issues, scoffed at the "ticking time bomb" scenario, calling the made up notion of an eleventh hour rescue a convenient means to justify the use of dubious information.
False confessions El Maati made under torture including a fictitious plan to attack the Parliament Buildings were used to obtain search warrants in Canada.
Critics want government to rescind torture directive
back up their irresponsible message to other countries that Canada is in the market for information based on torture. The government should oppose torture, no question about it," said Comartin.
OTTAWA Pressure is mounting on the federal government to scrap a policy that sanctions the use of torture tainted information in exceptional cases.
He points to the case of Ahmad El Maati, a dual Canadian Egyptian citizen who was arrested in November 2001 upon arriving in Syria, where family and friends planned to celebrate his marriage.
A copy of the two page directive, issued in December 2010 by Public Safety Minister Vic Toews, was obtained by The Canadian Press under the Access to Information Act.
less incentive for those governments to carry out torture in the first place."
The government once insisted the Canadian Security Intelligence Service would toss out such information, but is now telling the spy service to act on it to protect lives or property.
Conservatives to impose a total ban on material gleaned from abuse and mistreatment, saying Thursday there can be no exceptions when it comes to torture.
In a letter to Toews and CSIS director Dick Fadden, Amnesty International Canada called on the government to broadly interpret article 15 of the United Nations Convention against Torture, which prohibits the use of information derived through mistreatment as evidence in any proceedings.
"All of this is to Nike Air Max 90 White Grey Black
"They can't point to one example of that Nike Air Max 90 Ultra Essential ever happening before."
A total ban on the use of information that may have been elicited from torture is too far reaching, said Craig Forcese, a law professor at the University of Ottawa.
"The spirit of the ban in article 15 is clearly an attempt to dry up the market for torture," says the letter. "If governments are prohibited from making use of information gleaned through torture carried out or condoned by other governments, there is one Nike Air Max 90 Ultra Moire On Feet
Controversy has raged this week over revelations the government directed Canada's spy agency to use information that may have been extracted through torture in cases where public safety is at risk.
Defence Minister Peter MacKay stressed the federal position that "Canada does not condone torture and does not use torture. However, Canada will use information to save lives."
That prohibition should extend well beyond official legal proceedings, Amnesty argues.
"When will it rescind the directive?"
In turn that led to increased surveillance of other Arab Canadians including Maher Arar, who would also be tortured in a grim Syrian prison. The federal government later apologized to Arar and gave him $10.5 million in compensation.
Amnesty International Canada and the official Opposition urged the Nike Air Max 90 Forest Green
In the House of Commons, New Democrat MP Joe Comartin chided federal ministers for saying it would be irresponsible to ignore information even a possibly tainted tip about a bomb threat at the Air Canada Centre in Toronto or against a plane load of Canadians.
Such information should not be used in court or to arrest others, Forcese said, but could legitimately be used, for instance, to bolster security on a subway platform to guard against a possible terrorist bombing.
In a blog posting this week, Arar said that instead of clarifying Canada's position on the use of information obtained under torture, the federal directive "adds confusion to an already ambiguous and polarized debate."
"One thing is also sure: this directive is sending the wrong message to dictatorial regimes; you torture and we will return the favour by accepting and using your information."
Air Max 90 Mens Shoes
Nike Air Max 90 X Atmos Black Tiger Camo
Nike Vapormax Flyknit Moc Black
Nike Zoom Hypercross Red
Green Air Max 90
Air Max 90 White
Black Air Max 90 Essential
Nike Lebron Shoes 2017
Nike Air Max 90 Sneakerboot
Nike Air Max Green White
Air Max 90 Tinker
Nike Zoom Fit Agility Mens
Nike Metcon 3.0 Release Date
Nike Air Max Black Green
Nike Air Max 90 Hyperfuse Independence Day Red
TM et © 2005 Metropolitan Filmexport et ses entités affiliées. Tous droits réservés. Propriété de Metropolitan Filmexport. L'utilisation de ce site constitue une acceptation de nos termes & conditions d'utilisation et règles de protection de la vie privée. Les éléments graphiques, audio et textuels sur ce site ne peuvent être vendus, négociés ou distribués.Toute copie, manipulation, publication ou autre transfert de ces éléments, à l'exception de ce qui est expressément stipulé dans les Termes et Conditions d'Utilisation, est strictement interdit.