The decision is a setback for the families of several thousand former North Carolina based Marines suing the federal government in a separate case for exposing them to contaminated drinking water over several decades at Camp Lejeune. The government is relying on the same state law to avoid liability. Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta.
WASHINGTON (AP) The Supreme Court ruled Monday that a group of homeowners in North Carolina can't sue a company that contaminated their drinking water decades ago because a state deadline has lapsed, a decision that could prevent thousands of other property owners in similar cases from recovering damages after being exposed to toxic waste.
The high court reversed a lower court ruling that said federal environmental laws should trump the state law and allow the lawsuit against electronics manufacturer CTS Corp. to proceed.
The ruling Air Max 90 Hyperfuse Black And Red on Monday involves property owners living on land where CTS used to make electronics equipment until it sold the property in 1987. It wasn't until 2009 that residents discovered their well water contained chemicals that can cause numerous health problems including cancers, reproductive disorders and birth Nike Air Max 90 Essential Womens Black
Court rules against homeowners in toxic water case
Only four states other than North Carolina have statutes that place a similar time limit on property lawsuits: Connecticut (3 years), Kansas (10 years), Oregon (10 years) and Alabama Air Max 90 Gs Black
At Camp Lejeune, health officials estimate as many as 1 million people may have been exposed to tainted groundwater over several decades. In 2012, President Barack Obama signed a bill into law providing health benefits to Marines and family members exposed to the water from 1957 to 1987.
to pre empt statutes of repose. He said federal environmental laws only pre empt more traditional statutes of limitation, where the clock starts running at the time of the injury.
Ginsburg said the majority's decision "gives contaminators an incentive to conceal the hazards they have created until the repose period has run its full course." She was joined in dissent by Justice Stephen Breyer.
In dissent, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg said Congress was concerned about state statutes that "deprive plaintiffs of their day in court." That concern is apparent in the case of diseases like cancer that take years to develop before a victim understands the cause, she said.
North Carolina has a "statute of repose" that ends a plaintiff's right to seek damages to property more than 10 years after the last act of contamination occurred. The property owners argued that their claims were still valid under federal environmental laws, which give victims two years to sue from the date they discover what caused their illness.
Writing for the majority, Justice Anthony Kennedy said Congress did not intend Air Max 90 Tiger Camo
In a 7 2 decision, the justices said state law strictly bars any lawsuit brought more than 10 years after the contamination occurred even if residents did not realize their water was polluted until years later.
"The case for federal pre emption is particularly weak where Congress has indicated its awareness of the operation of state law in a field of federal interest, and has nonetheless decided to stand by both concepts and to tolerate whatever tension there is between them," Kennedy said.
Nike Metcon 1 Black And Grey
Nike Air Max 90 Laser Blue
Nike Air Max 90 Cheap
Nike Air Max 90 Ultra Essential Infrared
Nike Air Max 90 Bred
Air Max 90 Og Infrared On Feet
Nike Air Max 90 Ultra Br Mens Shoe
Nike Air Max Excellerate 2
Nike Air Max 90 Ultra Lotc
Nike Zoom Hyperrev 2016 Black
Air Max 90 Gs Blue
Nike Kyrie Gray
Nike Metcon Shoes For Sale
Air Max 90 Jd
Nike Zoom Basketball 2014
TM et © 2005 Metropolitan Filmexport et ses entités affiliées. Tous droits réservés. Propriété de Metropolitan Filmexport. L'utilisation de ce site constitue une acceptation de nos termes & conditions d'utilisation et règles de protection de la vie privée. Les éléments graphiques, audio et textuels sur ce site ne peuvent être vendus, négociés ou distribués.Toute copie, manipulation, publication ou autre transfert de ces éléments, à l'exception de ce qui est expressément stipulé dans les Termes et Conditions d'Utilisation, est strictement interdit.